WPRO’s Big Problem Filling the Cianci Time Slot — Who’s Next

Monday, February 01, 2016

 

View Larger +

Buddy Cianci was not just the controversial former Mayor of Providence turned radio talk show host, he was the money maker for WPRO AM, and its parent company Cumulus Media, company in the Providence market.

There are a few scenarios driven by cost, considerations of gender, and maybe most importantly the company's dire financial condition, as to who will fill Cianci's drive-time slot on WPRO.

SEE WHO MAY REPLACE CIANCI BELOW

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

For Cumulus, a company that does a more than a billion dollars in sales annually, but has seen its stock fall from a 52-week high of $4.51 per share to a Friday close of $0.26 — a 94 percent decrease in stock value, the decision is much more complicated due to a potential bankruptcy.

Cianci Drove As Much as 40% of the Revenue

According to sources, Cianci was by far the biggest revenue generator. Often his show was sold out both for drive-time spots and for live reads - the format in which the host personally endorses a product or service for a fee. Cianci, between his base salaries, incentives, and live reads made over $300,000, and drove the entire revenue machine and a time when both of the two largest U.S. radio groups have over 20 billion in debt and a shrinking audience. 

View Larger +

According to Pew Research Center, listening to radio news has decreased from 50% of the population to just 33% in 2015. Moreover, as the mega corporate groups continue to try to reduce costs, shifting WPRO from “live and local” from morning to night to a line-up that includes some syndicated content like a Michael Savage may be attractive during this time of corporate financial collapse. Public radio too is facing significant loss -- especially with young listeners.

"Average–quarter-hour (AQH) listening during morning drive time has dropped 11 percent in the past five years, and afternoon drive audience has declined 6 percent. The only age bracket that has increased listening to NPR stations is the 65-plus audience," reports Current, a publication that cover public broadcasting. Talk and news formats are decreasing and graying.

The WPRO brand used to be hosted by affable local voices like Salty Brine and Sherm Strickhouser and has morphed to tough nose conservative political talk fueled by Cianci and the controversial John DePetro. For two years union leaders have demanded that Democratic candidates and elected officials boycott spending on the station and appearing in interviews over DePetro.

As GoLocal reported in December:

The two biggest radio companies in the United States are on the verge of massive restructuring or bankruptcy, as they each have billions of dollars in debt and little chance of managing the building financial obligations.

How bad is the situation?  According to one leading radio analyst, the problem is catastrophic.  “$20.5 billion in debt for iHeart — billions more than the city of Detroit when it went bankrupt.  As I have been reporting, the venture capitalists are circling the carcass for a 2017 bankruptcy.  At Cumulus, new CEO Mary Berner has done nothing new except hire another person from outside the industry…They want to go bankrupt and her experience taking Readers Digest into Chapter 11 is her qualification to be CEO,” said Jerry Del Colliano, Publisher, Inside Music Media.

 

Related Slideshow: Filling the Cianci Time Slot

See the potential scenarios of who could fill Buddy Cianci's slot -- and the situations affecting the decision -- on WPRO.

View Larger +
Prev Next

Scenario #1

Move DePetro to Afternoon Drive

John DePetro used to host the morning drive up until 2010, but Dunkin’ Donuts - one of the largest advertisers on WPRO -- demanded DePetro be moved. The morning show has never matched the listenership that DePetro generated. His replacement was a morning show with a soft touch hosted by former TV anchor Andrew Gobiel and Tara Granahan, but that show’s rating plummeted and was replaced by WJAR Anchor Gene Vallicenti who stopped the bleeding, but has never come close to replicating DePetro’s ratings.

View Larger +
Prev Next

Scenario #2

Promote Tara Granahan

Presently, from 6 am to 9 pm, WPRO runs live and local with five shows all hosted by men -- Valicenti, DePetro, Dan Yorke, the late-Cianci and Matt Allen. Most recently, Granahan was a producer on Cianci's show and often filled in for the fomer Mayor, as she has been doing since his passing.  

Granahan will need to prove that her uninspired ratings in her previous effort were either the result of the poor formatting with Gobiel or that it is a different time and she has greater gravitas today.

View Larger +
Prev Next

Scenario #3

Cumulus Financial Reality - More Syndication

The loss of Cianci creates the opportunity for what Cumulus has done across the country — move multiple time slots to syndication. Cumulus in many markets across the country has blown out local talk talent with strong ratings and replaced it with syndicated shows. The combination of Cianci’s death and Cumulus’ financial struggles could be the impetus to replacing mid-day and evening with syndicated show.

Photo: Michael Savage with Dog source Twitter

View Larger +
Prev Next

Scenario #4

Big Shuffle

Not a likely scenario, but the death of Cianci could spark a complete reshuffling of Yorke to fill DePetro's slot, then DePetro to drive, Granhan or Allen to midday, and the other to fill the evening.

View Larger +
Prev Next

Scenario #5

New Faces

No matter how you shuffle the cards, the loss of Cianci is profound. There will be a significant number of Providence City Hall and State House radios that simply won’t “need” to listen to WPRO every afternoon without Cianci on the air. Thus, WPRO may need to bring on some new talent.

Former Congressional candidate John Loughlin - who hosts a weekend show — is one potential candidate. WPRO could bring in talent from another market - remember Yorke and Dave Barber were brought in from outside the market.

 
 

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.

 
 

Sign Up for the Daily Eblast

I want to follow on Twitter

I want to Like on Facebook